Yes: a soft-sided carryall is acceptable in the aircraft hold provided total external dimensions do not exceed 158 cm / 62 in (length + width + height) and the mass stays within the carrier’s allowance – standard economy: 23 kg / 50 lb; some premium or special allowances permit up to 32 kg / 70 lb at an extra charge. Measure including wheels, handles and any external pockets; weigh the packed item at home with a household scale before departure.
Do not pack high-value items such as laptops, passports, cash or jewelry; keep those in the cabin. Protect fragile contents by surrounding them with clothing, place heavy items near the base to keep the center of gravity low, and position sharp objects inside rigid containers. Seal all liquids inside leakproof secondary bags and place them centrally to minimize impact damage.
Choose a closure that secures: full-length zipper with internal storm flap preferred over simple drawstrings or roll-tops. Fit a TSA-approved lock if transit through TSA-controlled airports is possible; non-approved locks may be cut during inspection. Affix a sturdy external tag and include a paper ID and contact details inside the main compartment.
Expect fees and surcharges: typical first-piece checked-item charge on major U.S. carriers hovers around $30–35, second piece about $40–45; overweight penalties commonly range $100–200, while oversize surcharges depend on carrier policy. If connecting across different airlines, follow the most restrictive rule among them. When frequent rough handling or transport of fragile equipment is planned, consider selecting a rigid shell case instead of a soft-sided carryall.
Stowing a Soft Travel Sack in the Aircraft Hold: Recommendation
Recommendation: pick a reinforced, lockable soft travel sack with an internal frame or padded base and keep total weight ≤ 23 kg (50 lb) to meet most carriers’ aircraft-hold allowances and avoid overweight penalties.
Packing and protection
Place heavy items at the base near the wheel unit or external frame to keep the center of gravity low; cushion fragile articles with layers of clothing and a rigid insert; seal liquids in double zip-locks inside a dedicated toiletry pouch; close all fasteners, secure with a TSA-approved lock, and wrap external handles with brightly colored tape or a travel strap to create visual ID.
If travel includes maritime legs, prefer models tested in wet conditions–see best gear: catamaran sailing. Formal-occasion rain protection options appear at best formal umbrellas. Pre-trip equipment cleaning guidance is available at best pressure washer – personal.
Choosing the right soft case
Aim for 1680D ballistic nylon or PVC-coated tarpaulin with welded seams; a reinforced base plate plus external compression straps extends lifespan; full-length storm flaps over zippers reduce water ingress; pick coil zippers rated for heavy cycles and consider a removable frame if articles will be stowed in aircraft hold repeatedly.
Parameter | Recommendation | Typical target |
---|---|---|
Weight limit | Keep at or below | 23 kg / 50 lb |
Linear dimensions | Sum L+W+H under | 158 cm / 62 in |
Material | Water-resistant, abrasion-resistant | 1680D nylon or PVC-coated tarpaulin |
Closure | Coil zippers with storm flap | Reduced water entry, longer life |
Security | TSA-approved lock plus visible ID strap | Faster recovery, fewer tamper issues |
Which airlines accept soft-sided travel packs as hold items: size & weight limits?
Prefer soft-sided travel packs on carriers that list a 23 kg (50 lb) and 158 cm (62 in) allowance; when in doubt, keep each item under those limits to avoid extra charges.
American Airlines – standard hold-item maximum: 50 lb (23 kg) and 62 in (158 cm) linear. Overweight fees apply between 51–70 lb; items over 70 lb typically require cargo handling.
Delta Air Lines – standard allowance: 50 lb (23 kg) and 62 in (158 cm) linear. Overweight and oversize surcharges apply in two tiers (51–70 lb and above 70 lb), with cargo required for very heavy pieces.
United Airlines – standard allowance: 50 lb (23 kg) and 62 in (158 cm) linear. Fees added for 51–70 lb; >70 lb not accepted in the cabin/hold without special cargo arrangements.
Southwest Airlines – two free hold pieces on most fares; each piece up to 50 lb (23 kg) and 62 in (158 cm) linear. Heavier items incur overweight charges and may be refused if beyond airline limits.
British Airways – weight-per-piece model: economy pieces commonly limited to 23 kg (50 lb); maximum single-dimension limits cited as 90 × 75 × 43 cm (sum 208 cm) rather than the 158 cm linear rule used by many carriers.
Lufthansa – typical economy allowance: one piece up to 23 kg (50 lb) and 158 cm (62 in) linear; higher allowances apply in premium cabins and on certain international fares.
Air France / KLM – most economy fares: 23 kg (50 lb) and 158 cm (62 in) linear per item. SkyTeam partner and long-haul rules can increase the weight allowance.
Emirates – allowance varies by route and fare class; many economy fares permit 20–30 kg total per passenger under the weight-concept, while some itineraries use a piece-concept with per-piece limits. Maximum linear sizes and strict overweight thresholds apply; very heavy items often need cargo handling.
Qatar Airways – commonly applies a weight-based allowance (23–30 kg on many economy fares) or a piece-based allowance on some routes. Standard maximum linear dimension around 158 cm; excess weight charged progressively.
Turkish Airlines – many routes allow 20–23 kg per economy piece with 158 cm (62 in) linear max; some international itineraries use a piece concept (e.g., two pieces at 23 kg each).
Ryanair – hold items accepted only with a paid allowance; typical maximum per item around 20 kg and strict dimensional limits set at booking. Basic fares often exclude any paid hold allocation unless added.
easyJet – hold items available as an add-on; common per-item maximum 20–23 kg and combined-dimension caps (confirm the specific cap at purchase). Oversize or overweight pieces incur separate charges.
Aer Lingus – paid hold-item allowances vary by fare and route; common limits 20–23 kg and 158 cm (62 in) linear per item; extra-weight charges applied in tiers.
Always confirm the exact allowance shown on your itinerary before arriving at the airport; when planning, target 23 kg (50 lb) and 158 cm (62 in) per item as a practical baseline that satisfies most carriers.
Materials and reinforcements that survive airline conveyor handling
Choose 1680D ballistic nylon or 1000D Cordura paired with a rigid 3–5 mm HDPE base, #10 metal or VISLON zippers with covered storm flaps, welded or taped seams, and bar-tacked load points.
Primary fabrics
1680D ballistic nylon – abrasion-resistant weave used in high-wear soft cases; high tear strength and excellent resistance to conveyor belt scraping. Typical applications: base panels, exterior sides. Expect long-term surface scuffing resistance and minimal fiber breakdown.
1000D Cordura – high tensile strength and puncture resistance at a slightly lighter weight than 1680D; good choice where reduced weight is required without large durability loss. Best for main body panels.
TPU- or PVC-coated polyester (600D–900D) – waterproof outer shell when seams are welded; resists moisture, oil, and sticky contaminants on airport equipment. Optimal for wet climates or snow-prone routes.
Waxed canvas or full-grain leather accents – durable abrasion resistance on stress areas (end caps, handles), but heavier and requires maintenance; combine with synthetic main panels to limit weight.
Structural reinforcements and hardware
Rigid base plate – 3–5 mm HDPE or composite insert under the bottom panel prevents crushing, distributes weight, and protects against conveyor-edge impacts. Recommended: removable insert for cleaning and inspection.
Skid plates and rubber feet – 2–4 mm molded TPU or rubber plates at high-contact zones; replaceable inserts prolong service life and keep zipper seams off abrasive surfaces.
Seam construction – double-needle lockstitch with bar-tacks at all strap, handle, and zipper anchor points; stitch density of 8–10 SPI balances strength with fabric integrity. Critical seams sealed with welded tape when waterproofing required.
Zippers and sliders – YKK #10 metal or VISLON zippers with oversized teeth resist jamming and breakage; metal pullers with reinforced tape attachment reduce pull-off failures. Internal zipper garages or protective flaps prevent direct abrasion.
Hardware and webbing – 25–50 mm tubular nylon webbing with reinforced stitching at connection points; ITW Nexus or similar polymer buckles rated ≥2,500 N recommended for compression straps and lash points. Metal D-rings only where abrasion protection is provided.
Internal structure – molded EVA or low-profile foam frames maintain shape and prevent contents from shifting; internal compression straps reduce stress on exterior panels during conveyor handling.
Quick checklist: 1680D or 1000D shell, TPU/PVC coating if water exposure expected, 3–5 mm HDPE base, replaceable skid plates, bar-tacked seams at 8–10 SPI, YKK #10/VISLON zippers with storm flaps, 25–50 mm webbing and ITW hardware, welded/taped seams on waterproof models.
How to pack a travel holdall to protect clothes, electronics and fragile items?
Recommendation: Place electronics and breakables in the center, surround them with rolled garments, and add rigid padding next to exterior walls.
Roll shirts, underwear and socks tightly to create dense cushioning layers; reserve bulky items such as jeans and sweaters as outer padding around delicate cores. Compression cubes keep groups organized and reduce internal shifting.
Slip laptops and tablets into padded sleeves, then add a thin sheet of closed-cell foam plus two layers of bubble wrap. Position screens facing away from seams and zippers, aligned along the holdall’s long axis, with heavier electronic units closest to the base.
Wrap each glass or ceramic item in a soft garment, then add a second soft layer and two bubble-wrap layers; place wrapped items inside a small rigid box or reinforced pouch. Seal seams with tape and fill remaining empty space inside the parcel with socks to absorb shock.
Place liquids inside sealed, leakproof zip pouches; position these near exterior edges to limit spill contact with electronics. Store chargers, cables and power banks in labeled zip pouches; add silica gel packets inside electronic parcels to reduce moisture risk.
Stabilize contents with internal straps or a wide webbing strap across packed sections; fill voids with rolled socks or underwear to prevent movement during handling. Insert flat foam panels along both end walls when space allows to reduce compression from external pressure.
Attach a visible fragile tag to the exterior and photograph the interior layout before departure. Fasten lockable zipper pulls and an external compression strap around the holdall to increase security and maintain the packed arrangement.
Securing, labeling and locking a soft-sided holdall to meet TSA and airline rules
Lock with a TSA-recognized combination lock, attach both an external and an internal ID tag, photograph the airline barcode and keep valuables in carry-on.
Locks and tamper-evidence
Select locks displaying the Travel Sentry (red diamond) or Safe Skies logo since U.S. Transportation Security Administration agents have master keys to open and relock these. Non-recognized locks risk being cut without notice. Combination locks avoid key loss; if a keyed lock is chosen, stow a spare key on your person or in hand baggage.
Fit a numbered plastic security seal or heavy-duty nylon cable tie through zipper pulls and across the main opening as a tamper indicator. Expect seals to be removed if inspection is required, but they provide clear visual evidence of interference. Place small high-value items inside a locked hard-case within the soft-sided carrier to add an inner physical barrier should an external lock be compromised.
Labeling, documentation and tracking
Attach a weatherproof external tag with name, mobile number and email; avoid listing a full home address on the exterior to reduce theft risk. Place a duplicate ID card with full contact details and itinerary in an internal zip pocket sewn to the lining. Thread the external tag strap through a reinforced handle or D-ring rather than a zipper tab so the tag remains attached during automated handling.
Photograph the airline-issued barcode tag immediately after it is printed and capture the whole exterior from multiple angles; store images on your phone and in cloud backup. Keep a printed inventory of high-value contents including brand, model and serial numbers inside the item; present that list when filing a trace claim. Declare fragile or oversized contents at the ticket counter and request a fragile sticker if relevant.
Never place spare lithium-ion cells, passports, irreplaceable jewelry or expensive primary electronics in the aircraft hold. Lithium-ion rules: up to 100 Wh allowed in carry-on without airline approval, 100–160 Wh requires airline approval, above 160 Wh is prohibited from passenger transport. Verify the carrier’s lock and fragile-label policies before travel since international handling teams may not respect TSA master-key systems and could cut locks abroad.
Avoid Extra Fees, Overweight Charges, and File Damage or Loss Claims
Weigh and measure items at home; prepay extra-piece or overweight charges on the carrier website to reduce airport counter costs.
Avoiding extra fees and overweight penalties
- Confirm carrier allowance online 48–24 hours ahead: permitted dimensions, weight limits, free-piece policy, and online fee schedule.
- Target 1–2 kg (2–4 lb) under the published weight limit using a portable scale.
- Split heavy articles between the main hold item and a personal item to meet per-piece weight caps.
- Prepay overweight or additional-piece fees during online registration; counter rates tend to be $25–75 higher.
- When booking, compare hold-item policies across carriers; low-cost operators often charge $30–60 per piece plus separate overweight fees.
- Compress clothing with vacuum cubes or packing folders to maximize volume without adding weight.
- Keep valuables, essential documents, medications and fragile electronics in carry-on; many carriers limit liability on deposited items.
Overweight fee expectations and airport actions
- Typical fee ranges (subject to carrier): 23–32 kg (51–70 lb) – USD 50–150; 32–45 kg (71–99 lb) – USD 150–400; items above 45 kg usually processed as cargo at freight rates.
- If flagged at the counter, options often include shifting items into carry-on, transferring weight to another passenger, or paying an overweight fee online/promptly at the counter.
- Request a written receipt and reference number for any fee paid before leaving the desk.
- If packing error caused the excess, ask a supervisor to reopen and reorganize; success varies by agent and queue length.
Filing damage, delay or loss claims – exact steps and deadlines
- Report damage or missing content to the carrier service desk immediately on arrival; obtain an official report number (PIR or local equivalent) and a copy of the report.
- Capture timestamped photos of external labels, visible damage, internal contents and any broken hardware; retain all tags, straps and boarding receipts.
- Compile a detailed inventory with item descriptions, serial numbers, purchase dates and original receipts or invoices.
- Submit a written claim via the carrier website within contractual time limits: damaged items normally within 7 days from receipt, delayed deliveries within 21 days from delivery date, presumed loss after 21 days; attach the report number and supporting documents.
- Note international liability under the Montreal Convention: 1,288 SDR per passenger (approximately USD 1,700–2,000 depending on exchange rates); domestic limits and carrier terms may differ.
- If response delays exceed eight weeks or the claim is denied, escalate to the national aviation authority (DOT in the United States, CAA in the UK, or equivalent), then consider small-claims court or arbitration; preserve all correspondence, timestamps and call logs.
- Submit a parallel claim to travel insurance or the credit-card issuer that provided ticket protection; include the carrier report number and receipts to accelerate payout.
- Damaged electronics: do not discard the device; obtain an authorized repair estimate and keep defective parts. Request written salvage instructions from the carrier before disposing of any item.