Michael Turner
Immediate action recommended: obtain a Property Irregularity Report (PIR) at the carrier desk prior to leaving the terminal; retain the PIR reference, boarding pass, checked-bag tags and photographs of the bags and contents. Submit a written claim to the carrier’s baggage-claims office and keep proof of sending and any claim reference numbers.
International scheduled flights are typically governed by the Montreal Convention: liability covering checked baggage is capped at 1,288 SDR per passenger (≈ $1,700 USD at mid-2024 exchange rates) unless a higher value was declared at check-in and an additional fee was paid. Required written-notice deadlines under that treaty: damaged items – notice within 7 days of receipt; delay or non-receipt – notice within 21 days measured from the date the carrier placed baggage at passenger disposal or from the flight arrival when the item never appeared.
Documentation that materially increases recovery chances: original purchase receipts, serial numbers, product descriptions, photographs, checked-bag tags and boarding pass, PIR number, all written correspondence with the carrier, and an itemized list with values. Keep receipts relating to interim purchases of essentials; many carriers reimburse reasonable expenses up to a carrier-specific cap when notified and supplied with receipts.
If the carrier response is unsatisfactory, escalate to the national civil aviation authority or consumer-protection agency, pursue the matter in small-claims court where sums fit the threshold, or retain counsel to assess negligence claims that may go beyond treaty caps. The Montreal Convention imposes a two-year limitation period to commence court proceedings, counted from the date of arrival or the expected arrival date.
Domestic flights and low-cost operators often apply different conditions of carriage and liability ceilings; consult the carrier’s contract of carriage and ticket conditions immediately. Travel insurance and certain credit-card protections frequently cover amounts exceeding carrier liability; submit insurer claims after exhausting the carrier’s internal process, supplying identical documentation and claim references to accelerate reimbursement.
Can You Sue an Airport for Lost Luggage?
File a Property Irregularity Report (PIR) at the airline desk immediately; retain boarding pass, baggage tag(s), photos of bag(s) and contents, purchase receipts, and all email/text delivery notifications.
For international carriage governed by the Montreal Convention: submit a written claim within 7 days regarding damaged baggage and within 21 days regarding delayed baggage; a lawsuit must be filed within two years from actual or scheduled arrival (Article 35). Carrier liability is limited to 1,288 SDR per passenger (approximately $1,700–$1,900 depending on exchange rates at filing).
For domestic itineraries, consult the carrier’s contract of carriage and applicable state statutes; many carriers set specific claim windows and valuation methods. Use the carrier’s formal claims process first, send escalation letters by certified mail, and preserve all correspondence timestamps.
If settlement demands are rejected, bring an action against the air carrier, ground handler, or terminal operator depending on custody chain and contractual obligations; small claims court is often the most cost-effective venue, with monetary caps commonly between $2,500 and $25,000. Prepare a packet with the PIR, written claim, receipts, depreciation calculations, photos, and proof of travel.
Mitigation steps to maximise recovery: list contents with purchase dates and values, obtain repair estimates when applicable, and file claims with travel insurer or credit-card protection programs concurrently. To reduce recurrence, choose durable checked gear – see best luggage for baggage handlers at airport – and add external GPS tags plus durable straps to speed identification and strengthen replacement claims.
Who May Face Legal Claims over Missing Baggage: Carrier, Terminal Operator, Ground Handler?
File a claim initially against the air carrier that issued tickets and checked the bag; if the carrier refuses compensation, add the ground handling contractor and the terminal operator as additional defendants.
International travel governed by the Montreal Convention assigns primary liability to the contracting carrier; checked-bag compensation is limited to 1,288 SDR per passenger; damaged-bag notices must be submitted in writing within 7 days of receipt; delayed-bag complaints must be lodged in writing within 21 days; the limitation period to commence court proceedings is two years counted from the date the passenger could have discovered the loss.
Ground handling firms and terminal owners usually operate as independent contractors; civil liability arises under local tort and contract law when negligence during handling, screening, storage, transfer, or loading is established; indemnity clauses between carrier and handler often shift financial responsibility, and carriers commonly pursue subrogation against handlers after compensating the passenger.
Obtain a Property Irregularity Report (PIR) at the arrival terminal immediately; preserve boarding pass, bag tag stubs, baggage receipts, photographs of damage, repair estimates, and original purchase invoices; submit a written claim to the carrier within the applicable Montreal Convention deadlines and send identical documentation to any known handling company or terminal operator.
If contractual carrier response is inadequate, pursue a civil claim in small-claims court where the contract was formed or where the handler operates; many courts allow direct actions against handlers when an independent duty of care is proven, but jurisdictional limits, service issues, and indemnity clauses can complicate recovery–legal advice recommended before filing.
Domestic routes follow national statutes plus the carrier’s contract of carriage; liability caps, claim forms, and internal deadlines vary widely–review the contract of carriage and national aviation regulator guidance to identify the correct defendant and procedure.
Document all out-of-pocket expenses, notify relevant insurers and card issuers that provided purchase protection, keep copies of every communication, and monitor the two-year limitation period under international rules; if carrier denial rests on disputed facts, preserve physical evidence and consider expert valuation to strengthen a claim against the handler or terminal operator.
Immediate Steps at the Terminal: Filing a Property Irregularity Report and Preserving Evidence
File a Property Irregularity Report (PIR) at the airline baggage desk before leaving the terminal.
What to include in the PIR
Must contain: flight number; travel date; baggage tag numbers and claim-check identifiers; detailed, itemized description with estimated values and purchase dates; boarding pass number; delivery address and daytime phone and email; agent’s printed name and badge or employee ID; printed PIR copy with unique reference number and timestamp.
Evidence to preserve
Retain the boarding pass, checked-bag receipt and all bag tags; photograph the exterior damage, interior contents, tag attachments and carousel area; keep original packaging, purchase receipts and warranty cards; obtain a written repair estimate and keep repair invoices; save receipts for any emergency purchases at destination and made payments related to the incident; preserve damaged items until final claim resolution and avoid discarding parts or packaging; record names, badge numbers and direct contact details of every desk agent and supervisor; keep all email and SMS correspondence and note dates and times of telephone calls.
Under the Montreal Convention liability is limited to 1,288 Special Drawing Rights (SDRs) per passenger – convert at prevailing exchange rates and check carrier conditions that may set different domestic limits. Many carriers require claims filed within 21 days (unlocated baggage) and 7 days (damage); follow the carrier’s written claims process described on the PIR or the carrier’s website. Notify travel insurer and card issuer supplying travel benefits, attaching the PIR reference, photos and receipts, and keep copies of all submitted documents.
Statutes, International Conventions and Liability Caps That Limit Recovery
File claims within the two-year limitation under the Montreal Convention; declare high-value items at check-in and retain original purchase receipts plus serial numbers.
-
Montreal Convention (1999)
- Liability cap: 1,288 Special Drawing Rights (SDRs) per passenger in respect of checked baggage; higher liability available via written declaration and prepayment of an agreed sum.
- Time limit: two years from date of arrival or from the date when the aircraft should have arrived to commence judicial proceedings.
- Delay: carrier exposure for delay to baggage subject to treaty liability rules; monetary recovery limited by the same SDR ceiling absent declared value.
-
Warsaw Convention and Successor Regimes
- Older Warsaw-based limits remain applicable on certain routes where Montreal is not in force; those caps historically expressed in gold francs and often significantly lower than Montreal levels.
- Practical impact: treaty choice may restrict available recovery amounts and determine the governing damage calculation method.
-
Regional and National Statutes
- EU member states apply Montreal principles alongside consumer protection rules and national carriage statutes; carrier conditions of carriage must be checked to identify extra remedies or procedural steps.
- Domestic law may impose alternative limitation periods or caps for wholly domestic itineraries; jurisdictional analysis required when travel involves mixed domestic and international segments.
-
Liability of Third Parties
- Ground handling companies, terminal operators, and other service providers typically face liability under contract or tort; treaties often bind only the air carrier, so third-party recovery may follow different legal rules and caps.
- Contractual indemnities embedded in handlers’ agreements can shift financial responsibility, but recoverable sums remain subject to any statutory caps applicable to the underlying claim.
Practical rules and actions:
- Inspect the ticket, receipt and the carrier’s conditions of carriage to identify the governing treaty or statute and the exact cap expressed in SDRs or local currency.
- Declare value in writing at check-in when contents exceed the treaty cap; obtain the carrier’s written acceptance and payment receipt to secure higher recovery potential.
- Preserve documentary evidence: original receipts, serial/IMEI numbers, photographs, repair estimates, the Property Irregularity Report copy, and all correspondence with the carrier and handlers.
- When calculating expected recovery, convert SDR caps using the IMF SDR exchange rate applicable on the date specified by the claim handler or court; include conversion documentation in submissions.
- Assess supplemental coverage: travel insurance, homeowner/renter policies, and certain payment-card benefits frequently provide limits above treaty caps and may permit faster reimbursement.
- Evaluate alternative dispute venues such as small-claims courts where treaty caps render full judicial proceedings disproportionate to anticipated recovery.
Documentation and Receipts Needed to Prove a Missing-Baggage Claim
Collect boarding pass, ticket/itinerary receipt and checked-bag tag at the terminal, obtain a Property Irregularity Report (PIR) with reference number before leaving the facility, and photograph baggage tag(s) and external bag condition immediately.
Primary evidentiary items
Mandatory: original boarding pass; original ticket or e-ticket receipt showing passenger name and booking reference; original checked-bag tag(s); copy of the PIR containing the reference number and staff name. Supporting: original purchase invoices, serial numbers, warranty cards, dated product photos, and manufacturer documentation that establish ownership and value.
Receipts that substantiate incidental expenses and valuation
Keep original receipts for emergency purchases such as toiletry and clothing replacements; retain credit-card or bank statements that match purchase dates; hold repair invoices and professional appraisal documents when claiming high-value items; preserve packaging and tags when available. Keep repair invoices; example: how to troubleshoot and repair an air compressor pressure switch.
Prepare an inventory spreadsheet listing each item, purchase date, original price, serial number and receipt reference; attach corresponding photographs and scanned receipts. Convert all materials to high-quality PDF files, apply file names with ISO dates (YYYY-MM-DD) and upload copies to cloud storage while keeping an offline copy on external media.
Observe deadlines specified by the carrier or applicable treaty: visible damage must be reported within 7 days; non-delivery claims typically require submission within 21 days from the date baggage should have been available. Send written claims via tracked post or registered email and retain proof of dispatch and delivery.
Where to File: Small Claims, State Court or Federal Action Involving an Air Terminal
Opt small-claims court when claimed damages remain below the local monetary cap and evidence consists of receipts, repair estimates, and a property irregularity report issued at the terminal.
Common small-claims caps: California – $10,000; New York – $5,000; Texas – $20,000; Florida – $8,000; Washington – $10,000; Illinois – $10,000. Verify the precise limit in the jurisdiction where the event occurred prior to filing.
State superior court handles larger claims, permits full discovery, jury trials, and motions to compel testimony. Typical statutes of limitation range between two and three years depending on claim theory and state law; contract-based causes may use different limitations than tort-based theories.
When the defendant is a municipal or state authority, prelitigation notice statutes often apply; common notice windows include 90 days, six months, or one year. Failure to satisfy those notice duties may extinguish the claim; confirm the applicable tort-claim statute immediately.
Federal court admission requires either complete diversity plus amount in controversy exceeding $75,000 or a federal-question cause of action. Federal jurisdiction is appropriate only when jurisdictional prerequisites are clearly met, or when a federal statute specifically governs carriage or baggage liability.
Ticket terms and carrier websites frequently contain venue-selection clauses, mandatory arbitration provisions, administrative claim-exhaustion steps, and liability caps. Review the contract of carriage and any posted carrier policy before selecting a forum; arbitration clauses may require initiation of private dispute-resolution procedures prior to court filing.
Practical selection guidelines: choose small-claims when recovery estimate sits comfortably under the cap and priority is speed plus low filing expense. Choose state court when damages exceed the small-claims ceiling, complex discovery is necessary, or a government entity defendant triggers pre-suit notice obligations. Reserve federal court only when amount thresholds or federal causes are clearly satisfied.
| Forum | Typical monetary threshold | Typical turnaround | Typical costs | Special procedural hurdles |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Small-claims | Up to local statutory cap (examples above) | Weeks to a few months | Low filing fee; limited attorney involvement | No extensive discovery; nonbinding limited remedies in some jurisdictions |
| State court | No statutory upper limit | Months to years | Moderate to high (attorneys, discovery costs) | Statute of limitations; pre-suit notices when defendant is government entity; venue rules |
| Federal court | Typically > $75,000 for diversity jurisdiction | Many months; often longer than state court | High (federal filing fees, extensive discovery, higher counsel rates) | Strict jurisdictional prerequisites; potential removal by defendant; federal procedural rules |
Verify ticket terms, preserve receipts and the property irregularity report, calculate projected recovery net expected legal expenses, and file any statutory notices required by the relevant tort-claim statute prior to venue selection; retain counsel when recovery approaches jurisdictional thresholds or when a governmental authority is a named defendant.
