Michael Turner
Select models with a TPU or PU laminate and fully taped seams: laminated liners (thermoplastic polyurethane or polyurethane) plus factory seam-taping deliver watertight performance; woven nylon treated only with a durable water repellent (DWR) sheds light showers but soaks through during prolonged exposure or immersion.
Check measurable metrics on the spec sheet: hydrostatic-head ratings provide a useful benchmark – 1,000–2,000 mm handles light showers, 5,000–10,000 mm resists sustained heavy rain and pressure, while tarpaulin-style, 100% coated fabrics (e.g., 600D TPU) approach immersion-level protection. Prioritize welded seams, taped seam listings, roll-top closures or coated zippers over exposed coil zips and stitched external pockets.
Quick field checks: pour a liter of water across main seams and zippers for 30–60 seconds – beading and runoff indicate intact treatment or laminate; wicking along stitching or zipper leakage signals gaps. For electronics, pack items in sealed dry sacks inside the main compartment. Carry a compact rain cover rated for heavy use when crossing rivers or expecting sustained downpours.
Care and longevity: reapply external DWR every 6–12 months depending on abrasion and dirt; use proven wash-in or spray products from reputable reproofing lines. Clean per manufacturer instructions, avoid high heat that can delaminate coatings, and replace worn seam tape or zipper storm flaps rather than relying solely on superficial treatments.
Rain protection and real-world performance
Choose packs with fully laminated shells and factory seam-taping or carry a rain cover rated ≥2,000 mm hydrostatic head for extended exposure; for short showers a DWR-treated 500–900D polyester with water-resistant zippers usually suffices.
Key construction features that maintain dryness: TPU or PU laminate, welded seams, roll-top closures, and taped zipper channels. Hydrostatic head guidelines: 5,000 mm = reliable for prolonged immersion or torrential downpour.
Field test protocol I recommend: pack a phone and a paper notebook in the main compartment, spray 60 mm/hr for 1 hour (or simulate with a showerhead), then inspect for droplets at seams and zipper bases. Expect DWR-only fabrics to wet out within 30–90 minutes under heavy rainfall; laminated/taped builds keep contents dry much longer.
For electronics and important documents use internal dry bags (roll-top rated 10,000+ mm HH) or sealed zip bags; place heavy items at the base and keep critical items in upper compartments with secondary protection. A compact, stowable rain cover adds redundancy without much weight.
Maintenance and upgrades: renew DWR with a spray-on reproof after washing or once beading stops; re-seal needle-punched seams with a polyurethane seam sealer; avoid tumble drying on high heat. For commuters who need extra protection consider packing solutions listed at best luggage for dance competitions and a portable protective canopy like best umbrella for walkers.
Which models have impermeable shells versus water-resistant fabrics?
Recommendation: pick the Black Hole family (especially the duffels and MLC) for the strongest shell-level protection; choose Refugio, Arbor and Nine Trails lines when you need everyday water resistance with lighter weight and more breathability.
- Highest shell protection – laminated / welded construction (best for gear that must stay dry)
- Black Hole Duffels (various sizes) – 900D recycled polyester ripstop with TPU-film laminate; welded construction on many duffel models and weather-resistant main zippers; excels at shedding heavy rain and brief splashes; not rated for full submersion.
- Black Hole MLC / Black Hole Packs (25L, 32L, 55L) – same TPU-laminated face fabric and heavy DWR; packs use robust welded panels in high-wear areas and reinforced stitching; very high resistance to driving rain but seams on sewn pack models are not always fully taped.
- Strong water-shedding fabrics (coated laminates, robust DWR – good for long wet trips but less sealed than welded shells)
- Stormproof-style travel packs in the Black Hole lineup – laminated exterior fabric with water-repellent zippers on some variants; designed to keep contents dry during heavy showers and rough handling.
- Water-resistant woven fabrics (everyday use, commuting, school)
- Refugio and Refugio Daypacks – 600D recycled polyester or similar woven textiles with DWR finish; sewn construction without seam tape; solid for light-to-moderate rain when paired with a rain cover or dry bag for electronics.
- Arbor series – recycled woven polyester with DWR and vintage canvas look; water-resistant but not sealed; use for commuting and casual travel.
- Nine Trails and Ascensionist trail packs – lightweight nylon with DWR coating; sheds showers and trail spray but not intended to keep contents dry during prolonged exposure.
- Atom Sling and other small carry pieces – treated fabrics and taped seams rarely used; pack contents should be protected with internal pouches or liners for serious wet conditions.
Quick selection tips:
- Look for “TPU-film laminate,” “laminated ripstop” and “welded construction” in the product spec for the best external shell protection.
- If specs list only “DWR” or “water-repellent” and show sewn seams, plan to use a rain cover or dry sacks for electronics and documents.
- For long trips where submersion is possible, choose welded duffels or add a dedicated dry bag – even the most laminated shells are rarely guaranteed fully impermeable under submersion.
- Check the current product page before purchase: finishes, zippers and seam treatments can change between model years.
How to read product tags: H2No, DWR, laminated membranes and seam taping
Read the tag first: look for H2No, DWR, the words “laminated” or “coated”, and whether seams are labeled “fully taped” or “critically taped.” Those four items tell you expected liquid protection, breathability class, construction type, and seam sealing level.
H2No on a label signals the manufacturer’s proprietary performance standard: a bonded membrane plus factory testing for liquid entry and vapor transfer. If the tag also lists a hydrostatic head value, use it as a numeric guide (for reference, >10,000 mm indicates strong resistance to pressurized water; higher numbers mean greater liquid holdout). Breathability may be shown as g/m²/24h; higher numbers indicate more moisture vapor flow.
DWR (durable water repellent) is a surface finish that makes droplets bead. It is not a membrane: treated fabrics will shed light rain but will eventually “wet out” under prolonged exposure or abrasion. Reproof when droplets stop beading: wash with a technical cleaner, then apply a DWR reproof (wash-in or spray). Reactivate many DWR treatments with low-heat tumble drying if the care label permits.
Laminated membrane vs coated fabric: “laminated” or “membrane” means a separate waterproof/breathable layer (commonly PU or ePTFE) bonded to face fabric; labels may indicate 2.5-layer, 3-layer or 2-layer construction. 3-layer lamination = best durability and breathability for prolonged wet use; 2.5-layer = lighter, better packability, slightly less abrasion resistance. “Coated” means a polymer finish applied to one side of the textile – typically more affordable but less breathable and less durable under repeated flexing.
Seam taping terms: “fully taped” = all internal seams sealed with factory tape; “critically taped” = tape applied only to high-exposure seams (shoulders, hood, chest). No taping or only partial taping increases risk of leak at stitch lines. Inspect the interior for glossy tape strips along seams to confirm the label claim.
Quick in-hand checks: perform a spray test: toss cold water at the exterior and watch for immediate beading versus rapid absorption. Check inside pockets and along seams during a short pour test to detect leaks. Confirm label wording: “laminated membrane” and “fully taped” predict much higher liquid protection than “DWR” plus untaped seams.
Care and repair recommendations: use a product-specific technical cleaner before reproofing; avoid solvent-based sealants that can clog membrane pores. For worn DWR, reapply a PFC-free or PFC-based reproof according to the garment tag. For failing seam tape or delamination, send to the brand repair service or a specialist repair shop; DIY seam-tape patches and seam sealers (manufacturer-approved types) can work for small jobs but will not restore original laminated integrity.
Selection guidance: for prolonged exposure choose items labeled with a laminated membrane plus fully taped seams and higher hydrostatic ratings; for daily urban use choose DWR-treated fabrics with critical taping to balance weight and packability.
Home test for water ingress in a technical pack – step-by-step
Run two complementary checks: a 5–10 minute static submersion of the shell and a 3×60-second directional spray test focused on zippers, seams and closures.
Materials
- Large clear plastic bin or bathtub (big enough to submerge the pack)
- 2–4 white paper towels or single-use kitchen towels (trim to fit inside compartments)
- Spray bottle (adjustable nozzle) or household showerhead/garden hose with fan setting
- Stopwatch or smartphone timer
- Flashlight for interior inspection
- Digital kitchen scale (optional) for weight-change check (±10 g sensitivity preferred)
- Small syringe or 250 ml cup for controlled pours
- Towel for drying and marks
Step-by-step tests
-
Preparation (2–3 minutes)
- Empty all pockets and remove removable hipbelts or foam inserts.
- Place one folded white towel inside main compartment and one in each enclosed pocket you want to test.
- If using a scale, record dry weight of the pack to detect water uptake later.
-
Static submersion shell check – 5–10 minutes
- Fill bin with tap water to a level that covers most of the bag but leaves top handles accessible.
- Slowly lower the pack so seams and shell are submerged; keep straps out of the water if they attach to the lid or overflow areas.
- Maintain submersion for 5 minutes. Rotate pack 90° after 2.5 minutes to stress different seam orientations.
- Remove pack, blot exterior dry, open compartments, inspect towels under flashlight within 30–60 seconds.
- Pass criterion: towels remain fully dry. Fail criterion: any visible damp patch on a towel indicates ingress.
- If using scale, compare weight. Water uptake >20 g usually signals meaningful leakage (fabric wetting or internal soak).
-
Directional spray test for zippers, flap closures and seams – 3×60 seconds
- Hang the pack on a hook or chair so it sits as it would when worn.
- Set spray nozzle to medium-fine fan or use showerhead. Hold 15–30 cm (6–12 in) from surface.
- Spray continuously for 60 seconds focusing on the zipper line, then 60 seconds on the lid and flap overlap, then 60 seconds along each major horizontal seam.
- After spraying each area, open the corresponding pocket and inspect the towel within 10–20 seconds.
- Pass criterion: no dampness on towels after any spray stage. Minor damp staining on exterior fabric without interior wetting is acceptable for repellant finishes.
-
Targeted zipper channel / closure check – controlled pour
- Place a towel directly behind the zipper or closure inside the pocket.
- Use a syringe or 250 ml cup to pour 100–200 ml of water slowly along the zipper teeth or the seam where two panels meet.
- Observe towel for 30–60 seconds, then press lightly on seam to simulate real pressure and re-check.
- Pass criterion: no transfer of moisture to towel. If moisture appears only after pressing repeatedly, expect limited protection under pressure but possible seepage under sustained exposure.
-
Backpanel and hipbelt attachment areas – 60–120 seconds
- Spray junctions where hipbelt/webbing connect to the bag and where the backpanel joins the main shell for 1–2 minutes total.
- Inspect internal cavities or pass-throughs (hydration sleeve, backpanel pockets) for moisture.
-
Interpretation and next steps
- No interior wetting in any test: shell and closures resist ingress at household-level exposure.
- Slight exterior wetting but dry interior: durable water-repellent or coated fabric functioning as intended; consider reproofing treatment if surface wetting persists.
- Moisture at seams or zipper teeth: apply seam sealer or zipper-specific lubricant/cover; repeat test after repair.
- Significant interior wetting: avoid storing electronics in main compartment; consider professional repair or use of dry bags for protection.
-
Cleanup and repeatability
Top Rated Liquid Rubber Seam Tape for RepairsFix leaks on various surfaces easilyThis peel-and-stick seam tape bonds to numerous materials, making it ideal for various repairs including RV and metal roofs. It’s easy to apply and starts adhering immediately for quick fixes.- Dry the pack fully (air dry 24 hours, avoid direct heat). Re-run failed tests after any repair or reproofing.
- Document test conditions (water temperature, spray distance, durations) for repeatable comparisons.
Practical ways to add protection: rain covers, pack liners, seam sealing and reproofing
Use a dedicated rain cover 10–20% larger than external pack volume to shed driving rain and keep zippers from wicking; choose models with reflective trim and strap closures that allow access to hipbelt and shoulder straps without removal.
Inside protection: place sensitive items (electronics, documents, sleeping kit) into welded-roll dry sacks or TPU zip sacks. Match dry-sack volume to pack load: 20–30 L for day use, 30–50 L for overnight, 50–70 L for multi-day. For ultralight setups use Dyneema Composite Fabric (DCF) dry bags at 40–120 g; for budget kits choose PU/nylon welds at 60–250 g.
Layering tip: double-bag small electronics using a zip-top plastic bag inside a 3–5 L dry sack. Add 1–2 small silica gel packs per electronics pouch when storing in wet climates to suppress moisture build-up during multi-day trips.
Seam treatment for stitched seams: inspect interior seam lines. If seam tape present, skip liquid sealant. For exposed stitched seams use a polyurethane or silicone seam sealant in a tube or squeeze bottle. Procedure: clean seam with mild soap, rinse, wipe with 70% isopropyl alcohol, apply a thin even bead along inside seam, smooth with a plastic spatula, allow 12–48 hours cure at 10–25°C. Apply a second thin coat to high-stress seams for added abrasion resistance.
Heat-activated seam tape repairs: use 12–25 mm heat-activated tape and a household iron on medium setting with a cotton press cloth. Test tape and temperature on scrap fabric first. Apply pressure for 20–30 seconds per section, then let cool without movement for 10 minutes.
Reproofing fabric finishes (DWR maintenance): wash technical fabric with a non-detergent tech cleaner (Nikwax Tech Wash, Grangers Performance Wash or equivalent), spin dry, then apply a spray-on or wash-in DWR product (Nikwax TX.Direct, Grangers Performance Repel, Gear Aid Revivex). Use spray-on for laminated or multi-layer fabrics to avoid altering breathability. Dry at ambient temperature for 6–24 hours; heat activation where permitted by manufacturer (dryer low heat for wash-in products) improves bead formation.
Frequency guidance: reapply DWR after 8–20 washes or when beading stops and fabric wets out; reseal stitched seams after any seam repairs or if visible thread exposure occurs.
Minimal repair kit to carry: 1 small tube (10–20 ml) of seam sealant, 50 mm rolls of heat-activated seam tape, 2–3 Tenacious Tape patches, 2 small zip-top bags, and a few silica packs. For extended travel add a lightweight TPU dry sack sized to main compartment.
| Use case | Recommended item | Key specs | Typical cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commuter / daypack | Pack rain cover, 20–30 L dry sack | Cover fits 15–30 L; dry sack 3–6 L; reflective trim | $12–35 for cover; $8–20 for dry sack |
| Overnight / weekend | Roll-top TPU dry bag 30–50 L + seam sealant tube | TPU welded seams, 70–150 g; sealant 10–20 ml | $20–50; $8–18 for sealant |
| Multi-day / technical | Dyneema (DCF) dry sack 40–120 g + heat-activated seam tape | Ultralight DCF, welded; tape 12–25 mm width | $40–120; tape $6–15 |
| Fabric finish maintenance | Tech cleaner + DWR (spray-on or wash-in) | Cleaner 300–500 ml; DWR 200–400 ml; follow temp limits on label | $10–25 per bottle |
