Michael Turner
Most full-service airlines permit a cabin bag plus a smaller under-seat item. Typical maximum for a cabin carry is 22 x 14 x 9 in (56 x 36 x 23 cm). A common personal-item target that must fit under the seat is 18 x 14 x 8 in (45 x 35 x 20 cm). Major US carriers (American, Delta, United) follow the 22x14x9 guideline and generally do not publish strict weight caps for hand luggage.
Budget operators frequently restrict the free allowance to a single compact item. For example, Ryanair’s free small-item limit is 40 x 20 x 25 cm; adding priority or a paid cabin option raises the allowed cabin size to roughly 55 x 40 x 20 cm. Low-cost lines often enforce both size and weight limits on paid cabin items (weights commonly set around 7–10 kg).
Measure both bags externally and weigh them fully packed with a luggage scale before heading to the airport. If an extra cabin item incurs a fee, wear the heavier rucksack on your body and place the smaller bag under the seat. Keep liquids, electronics and valuables in the under-seat item to reduce the chance of gate-checking.
Connections on different carriers mean the strictest operator’s rules apply across the itinerary. At gate or kiosk, staff evaluate dimensions first; oversized items are either checked into the hold or charged a gate fee. Typical gate-check or oversize charges range from about $25–$75 on US routes to €60–€100 on some European budget services; purchasing priority or extra cabin allowance online ahead of travel is usually cheaper than paying at the gate.
If policy wording is ambiguous, use the carrier’s baggage-size chart and save a screenshot or PDF of the allowance and any paid add-ons; present that proof at check-in or the gate if a dispute arises.
Carrying a Pair of Rucksacks on a Flight
Pack a compact daypack to fit under the seat (approx. 45×35×20 cm / 18×14×8 in) and a larger rucksack for the overhead bin only if your carrier’s rules explicitly allow a cabin bag plus a personal item.
- American Airlines – cabin bag 22×14×9 in; under-seat item 18×14×8 in. Fees apply for oversized pieces.
- Delta – cabin bag 22×14×9 in; smaller item must fit beneath the seat in front.
- United – cabin bag 22×14×9 in; personal item dimensions similar to other major US carriers.
- Ryanair – non-priority: single small item 40×20×25 cm; priority: add 55×40×20 cm cabin bag.
- British Airways – one cabin bag (56×45×25 cm) plus a smaller item for under-seat storage.
Practical steps at each stage
- Before booking: read the airline’s baggage page for your specific fare class; allowances vary by route and ticket type.
- Measure loaded rucksacks with a tape measure and weigh each piece with a handheld scale; some carriers enforce both size and weight at gate.
- Use compression sacks or packing cubes to reduce volume; place liquids (≤100 ml each) in a single transparent 1 L resealable bag and keep it in the under-seat item for screening.
- At check-in or gate, if staff refuse the pair, request to gate-check the larger rucksack or buy priority/priority boarding to retain both onboard.
- If frequent flights require dual carry items, choose one bag with expandable capacity that still meets the strictest low-cost carrier dimensions.
Quick checklist
- Know exact dimensions allowed by carrier and fare.
- Weigh both pieces before leaving home.
- Keep passport, medication, electronics and liquids in the under-seat item.
- Have a backup plan: gate-check, consolidate, or upgrade to a fare with a cabin allowance.
For post-trip fabric or zipper scuff removal, consider equipment such as best pressure washer sandblasting kits to restore external panels; test on a hidden area first.
How to determine if an additional daypack counts as a carry-on or personal item
Verify the airline’s cabin-baggage policy page and measure the additional daypack against the carrier’s stated dimensions and weight; if it fits the under-seat measurements it’s usually a personal item, if it matches overhead limits it will be treated as a carry-on.
Step-by-step verification
1) Open the airline’s official baggage page and find “carry-on”, “personal item” or “cabin baggage” sections; note both dimension and weight limits (examples below). 2) Measure length × height × depth of both pieces with a tape measure and weigh them on a scale. 3) Compare your measurements to the carrier’s numbers and to any fare-class or elite-status exceptions listed on the same page. 4) If the policy wording is ambiguous, check the airline’s FAQ and ticket restrictions for phrases such as “one carry-on plus one personal item” versus “one cabin bag allowed”.
Typical reference figures: overhead carry-on ~22 × 14 × 9 in (56 × 36 × 23 cm); under-seat personal item ~17–18 × 13–14 × 8–9 in (43–46 × 33–36 × 20–23 cm). Low-cost carriers often restrict the free item to a much smaller bag (examples around 40 × 30 × 20 cm) unless extra priority or seat bundles are purchased.
Practical checks at the airport and tickets
Check your boarding pass and the airline app for baggage allowances tied to the ticket. At the airport, use the sizer at bag drop or gate and be ready for gate agents to reclassify oversized items; soft-sided secondary bags that compress are more likely to pass as personal items. If measurements are borderline, keep essential electronics and documents in the smaller item to strengthen the under-seat claim. For compact luggage choices that fit strict limits see best luggage for travelling around japan.
How to measure and weigh a pair of rucksacks to meet airline size and weight limits
Recommendation: measure external dimensions with all pockets zipped and straps secured, then target at least 1–2 cm and 300–500 g under the carrier’s published cabin limits (for checked allowance aim ~1 kg margin).
Measure dimensions on a flat surface: place each pack upright on its base, include wheels, feet and fixed handles. Record height (base to highest rigid point), width (widest lateral point) and depth (front-to-back with pockets expanded). Use centimetres as primary units; report inches only after conversion (1 in = 2.54 cm). For a common cabin limit 55 × 40 × 20 cm, set your internal target to 54 × 39 × 19 cm.
For checked items measure linear dimension (length + width + height). If the airline limit is 158 cm linear, aim for ≤155 cm. When assessing compressible fabric, measure while compressed with compression straps engaged and secondary pockets zipped – that yields the practical packed profile gate staff will judge.
Weighing procedure: use a digital hanging luggage scale (accuracy ±50 g). Zero the scale, attach to the main handle, lift steadily and record when the display stabilises. If using a bathroom scale, weigh yourself, then weigh while holding the loaded pack and subtract your body weight; repeat for the second pack. For the pair, weigh individually and together (hold both) to verify any combined restrictions or surprises at the gate.
Calibration and verification: test your handheld scale with a known weight (1 L bottle ≈1.0 kg). Note units on the display (kg vs lb) and switch if needed. If readings differ by more than 100–200 g from the bottle test, use the bathroom-scale subtraction method as a cross-check.
Volume and weight control tactics: remove removable straps, luggage tags and external accessories prior to measuring; empty external mesh pockets; use compression cubes or a vacuum bag to reduce depth but remember compression affects volume, not mass. To drop a few hundred grams, swap full-size toiletries for 100 ml/50 ml travel bottles, replace heavy adapters with lighter models, and move dense items (chargers, batteries, shoes) between the two packs so the one destined for cabin holds the lighter load.
Quick pre-flight checklist: 1) measure zipped and compressed. 2) include handles/wheels. 3) record cm and inches. 4) weigh empty and fully packed. 5) allow the recommended margin (300–500 g for cabin, ~1 kg for checked). 6) re-weigh after final repack. Keep your handheld scale in the carry set for last-minute verifications at home or the hotel.
Security and gate: handling multiple carry packs
Place each pack separately on the X‑ray belt and keep your boarding pass and ID in hand. Consolidate all liquids, gels and aerosols into a single quart‑sized clear bag (containers 3.4 oz / 100 ml or smaller) and put that bag on top of a pack for immediate screening.
Electronics: Remove laptops and large devices from whichever bag they are in unless using an expedited screening lane (TSA PreCheck or CT scanner). Place each device flat in its own bin; tangled chargers and power banks slow the line.
Power banks and batteries: Spare lithium‑ion batteries must remain in carry items. Limit to batteries under 100 Wh without airline approval; 100–160 Wh require airline permission; >160 Wh prohibited. Have watt‑hour ratings visible or on packaging.
Medications and special items: Prescription meds, baby formula and breast milk in quantities above 3.4 oz are allowed but must be declared and removed for separate screening. Keep prescriptions or a physician note accessible.
If a security officer requests a secondary inspection, cooperate and offer to open compartments. Use a small clear pouch for cables, SIM cards and USB sticks so agents can quickly see contents and avoid repeated searches.
At the gate: Expect staff to monitor overhead bin capacity; additional carry packs may be tagged for gate‑check if bins fill. Gate‑check is usually free but rules vary by carrier–move valuables, fragile items and essentials (ID, wallet, phone, meds, chargers) into the item you will keep on your person before handing anything over.
Arrive at the gate early and board in your assigned group to maximize bin space. Use low‑profile packing (compressible cubes, flattened garments) so a single carry suitcase can absorb a second pack if asked to consolidate.
Label every pack with name and phone number, secure loose straps, and have a lightweight tote or crossbody available to transfer must‑have items quickly if an item is gate‑checked.
How to pack and board to avoid paying for a second carry-on
Recommendation: consolidate belongings into one overhead-sized bag and one under-seat personal item, place electronics and liquids in the under-seat item for quick removal during screening, and wear your bulkiest outerwear to free up internal volume.
Target dimensions to meet most carriers: overhead bag no larger than 22 x 14 x 9 in (56 x 36 x 23 cm); under-seat personal item roughly 18 x 14 x 8 in (45 x 35 x 20 cm). Low-cost carriers often limit the free under-seat item to about 40 x 20 x 25 cm; check the operator’s published measurements and use a luggage sizer at home to verify fit before arrival.
Packing technique: roll garments, use 3–4 small packing cubes instead of one large one, compress bulk with a manual compression sack for jackets, and store shoes and toiletry bottles inside shoe cavities. Put dense items (chargers, power banks, foldable umbrella) close to the pack spine to keep balance and reduce perceived volume.
Weight control: weigh the assembled cabin bag on a handheld scale – aim for at least 10–15% below any posted limit used by the carrier that enforces bag weight. If a carrier has no carry-on weight rule, prioritize size compliance; excess mass makes gate agents more likely to request checking.
Wearing strategy: use a layered outfit with a heavy jacket and boots on travel day; transfer one bulky sweater and any spare shoes to the worn outfit. Use outerwear pockets for passports, boarding passes, and a phone to keep the under-seat bag lighter and flatter.
Screening and gate tactics: keep the under-seat item with liquids and laptop accessible; fold soft items on top to allow rapid removal of electronics. Arrive at the gate early for overhead bin space; if bins are full, offer the agent to gate-check the larger bag (usually free and returned at the jet bridge). If the carrier enforces fees for cabin bags, request a courtesy gate check rather than paying if the flight is full.
Quick checklist before leaving for the airport: verify carrier dimensions online, measure both pieces with a tape, weigh the larger piece, pack valuables and documents into the under-seat item, wear heavy layers, and have a slim, collapsible daypack ready to compress into the under-seat item if needed. For a compact, unexpected accessory idea see best umbrella meme.
